STEVE MARSLING and CHRIS SMITH
This article first appeared in 2021 Volume 63 Number 2 of The Journal: Forum for Promoting Comprehensive Education published by Lawrence and Wishart FORUM 0963-8253 - Lawrence Wishart (lwbooks.co.uk)
This year sees the release of London Recruits, a film chronicling the anti-apartheid activism of young men and women volunteers who travelled from the UK to South Africa in the 1970s. The recruits were invaluable to the campaigning work of the African National Congress and the wider international anti-apartheid movement because as white tourists, which is all the South African authorities saw them as, they were free to travel unmonitored in ways impossible for black citizens. To coincide with the release of the film, an education pack, comprising the testimonies of the recruits as well as other source material has been compiled for use in schools. It was funded by the National Education Union and coordinated by Steve Marsling, a former recruit, who writes the first section of this article.
Chris Smith writes the rest. Chris, a serving history and politics teacher, helped provide learning activities and exemplar lesson plans so teachers can quickly make use of the pack in their classrooms. Work to create these educational resources started just before the upsurge of Black Lives Matter activity in the UK sparked calls for “de-colonising the curriculum”. It is hoped this pack shares and compliments that goal. As the story of the recruits makes clear, there have always been those who have needed to resort to direct action to have their voices fairly heard. Institutional racism is an undeniable feature of life in all nations whose pasts are closely entwined with imperialism. It is hoped this pack will form part of the continuing work in our schools to teach a more diverse curriculum, not only in subjects such as history but also in citizenship, creative arts and even during pastoral time. Teachers are struggling with unprecedented and seemingly endless demands: may this pack help them tell a story that until now had been largely untold.
Who were the London Recruits and what did they do? Steve Marsling writes…
After the Sharpeville Massacre in 1960, the world became more aware of the terrible consequences of the most brutal totalitarian state that was the South African Apartheid System. By the late 1960’s the brutal repression of the African working class was beginning to take its toll. After the Rivonia Trial the leadership of the African National Congress (ANC) was either imprisoned or in exile or murdered. The Apartheid Regime was crowing that white supremacy would last for a thousand years.
Oliver Tambo, the ANC leader-in-exile, and fellow-leader Ronnie Kasrils, knew they had to find a way of informing the majority population that they were still alive and kicking. But how to do that? They hit upon the idea of asking young white people opposed to the Apartheid Regime to carry out activities to prove that the ANC had not gone away. It had to be white people as only they had freedom of movement. The majority of young people that volunteered were members of the Young Communist League. Others were from the Socialist Workers’ Party or were politically unaffiliated.
One of the ideas was to set up leaflet-bombs. As you could not hand out leaflets critical of the government (five years’ imprisonment awaited anyone who did) a small explosive device would blast the leaflets up in the air. The idea was to set these devices off during rush hour so African workers could snatch them up and take them back to the townships where they could be read and distributed. The leaflet bombs were neither intended nor designed to harm anyone, and indeed they never did.
Some of the recruits were captured, tortured and served long prison sentences. As the ANC began to organize again inside South Africa, the need for white recruits and leaflet-bombs receded. As recruits, we were all sworn to secrecy. None of us knew one another, or if we did we didn’t know about each other’s adventures.
After the Apartheid Regime was defeated and Democratic Elections were held, one of the Recruits, Ken Keable, began the task of contacting the rest with the aim of putting their stories in print. In 2012, London Recruits: the Secret War against Apartheid was published by Merlin Press. Much media interest followed its publication and newspapers both here and in South Africa followed the story. For a left wing book, sales were very high.
Film companies were very interested in bidding for the film rights, with Barefoot Rascals the company which eventually secured them. In 2021 the film will be completed. It will feature South African locations, and dramatic scenarios in which the Recruits were involved. Actors will play the Recruits, with Recruits themselves also speaking on film.
Sometime in December 2019 I was invited by ACTSA (Action for Southern Africa), to speak about the Recruits in a London school. The talk went well and the students seemed keen to know more, but resources to do with the history of the anti-apartheid struggle were few and far between in schools. The Anti Apartheid Movement (AAM) Archive, which is located in the Bodleian Library, is a fantastic resource and has been invaluable in helping me with research activities.
I asked my fellow Recruits if they would help put together a Teacher /Pupil Resource Pack that could be used in schools. A group of Recruits began to gather both their individual case studies and relevant histories of the fight against Apartheid, what Apartheid was, and the final celebrations of the ultimate victory.
We asked Christabel Gurney, the Archivist of the AAM if we could use some of the Anti-Apartheid collection of photos, posters and badges to illustrate the material that we had produced. This has been a tremendous help, and our thanks go to Christabel and David Kenvyn for all their support they have given to the project.
We then spoke to Gawain Little, the Chair of the International Committee of the National Education Union. His enthusiastic support and sound advice has been key to the pack’s success. We asked for and were awarded a £2,500 grant to pay for designers to make a PDF resource that schools could use for 14/15 year olds. More importantly, Gawain introduced me to Chris Smith a young Politics teacher in a comprehensive school in Norwich.
Chris’s task was to suggest classroom activities to go with the Resource Pack. The Pack contains many suggestions for how the resource material can be delivered. It is hoped that the pack will be ready for the term beginning in September 2021.
The London Recruits: a resource-pack for teachers. Chris Smith writes
My first introduction to the story of the London Recruits came when I was asked to look over resources and recommend classroom activities or lesson plans that could help turn this material into classroom-ready packs to be sent to teachers. As a teacher of politics and history for 7 years, and before that a graduate of international relations and politics, and always as an active trade unionist and political party member I had never encountered the story of the London Recruits. Reading the first-hand experiences of what went into the struggle against apartheid it was immediately obvious to me that this was a story worth telling and one that, when combined with the professional judgment of classroom teachers, would require relatively little in terms of prescriptive activities or lesson plans. Rather, what was essential was some exposition, to ensure that teachers with even less familiarity with the anti apartheid struggle than myself would be confident in using the materials and in helping their students appreciate the universality of these stories and the importance of human solidarity which they underscore.
I was asked to help with the project before the explosion of the Black Lives Matter movement in the UK felled statues of slave owners and drew attention to the pressing need to de-colonise the curriculum. It was, however, after the Covid pandemic had cancelled the summer’s exam series. This cancellation offered hope that, in the inevitable debate about how education was to “build back better”, it might be possible to highlight the extent to which England’s school curriculum had become dependent upon preparation for exams, at the expense of more humanising elements. This project offered the perfect example of a worthy topic with cross-curricular potential. In previous years such a topic would have been consigned to a footnote in the sole History or Citizenship lesson assigned to Nelson Mandela, but now it could be given the time it deserved. A resource-pack could make its way into the hands of teachers searching for just such a thing with which to engross students and kindle a love of learning rather than to cram them for tests. The entirely correct debate around diversifying the curriculum and creating an educational offer inclusive of modern Britain, which Black Lives Matter has ushered in, serves only to reinforce how the story of the London Recruits is one for our times. This means the pack isn’t simply a collection of primary source material to be used in History lessons, but can be used across subject-domains—for example in English, Citizenship, Geography, Music, Art and Design—to study not just the people involved but also how they campaigned for change through the written word music, poetry and art.
Hooking imagination; empowering agency.
The real value of this project lies in the quality of the personal testimonials on offer, as well as in the vast wealth of visual materials such as posters, badges, photographs and even video recordings such as of the ‘Free Nelson Mandela’ concerts. The potential all this offers to hook the imagination of students is huge. Partly this is due to the connection with a figure like Mandela who, quite rightly, the majority of primary and secondary school children will be aware of, but whose awareness is by no means likely to be a fully developed one that could place Mandela in a historical context and then connect that to their own lives. As my own lack of knowledge shows, the same could be true for many teachers. They can feel confident in the value of this project due to Mandela’s presence in its narrative, a historical figure as close to being universally admired as it is possible to get. The project also offers the potential for that most joyous of school projects, one through which a teacher can learn about alongside their students.
In designing the few activities and plans that accompany the pack, I was determined never to be prescriptive. Prescription could discourage teachers, who only have limited time in which to address elements of the curriculum time. Most importantly, a prescriptive stance would undermine their professional agency. Classroom teachers know best what their students will find appealing, challenging or inspiring, and also how much or how little they will be able to engage with productively and explore in whatever time is available.
Issues of assessment
A further liberating experience came to me as I was compiling ideas. Whilst I was essentially creating a unit of work, as I have done many times, I was doing so without including any formal summative assessment which the whole project was geared towards, as would be the case if I were making something similar for my school, where the outcomes of all modules of study are measured in ‘knowledge test scores’ and essay grades. This isn't to say the whole project is devoid of assessment opportunities by which a teacher may gauge what students have taken away from their studies. Far from it. Most tasks I recommended follow a simple pattern which involves students answering open questions to help them connect with key elements of a text. Responses may be assessed in the classroom as teachers think best, to help them feel confident students have made meaningful progress. Students can then be asked to apply their new knowledge in a creative task, such as by designing their own campaigning materials for an issue that motivates them. Assessment here might be via performance or sharing in class, for all students to see and comment on. Such commentary is in its own way assessment.
No mark schemes or model answers have been supplied, and the idea of including such things never occurred to me until I reflected upon it just now. The whole purpose of this project is to give students opportunities to think critically about the facts as they see them, not to teach didactically about the historical record in a “facts, facts, facts” fashion. This stance has implications both for historical facts and for modern facts, as history is nothing if we cannot appreciate how the past bears upon and parallels our own times. This narrative is a world away from the one common to rest of my classroom teaching career to date of effectively only teaching what advances students towards a test sooner or later. This in itself reveals why Covid has been so destabilizing to education in England, as soon exams were cancelled, or even serious doubt arose that they may take place the whole purpose of what went on inside classrooms disappeared with them. I remember this feeling being a tangible one inside my school at least felt by not teachers but students too, whose first question was “what about our exams” when the rumors of school closures began circulating.
Since returning to the class room there has rightly been debate of what should and shouldn’t be included in school curricular. Unfortunately there is a significant disconnect between the profession itself and education policy makers. Teachers on the whole talk the language of a more inclusive curriculum relevant to the modern society their classrooms are drawn from policy makers prioritize the poorly substantiated narrative of “making up for lost time” and “rapid catch up” which unless accompanied by a stark change for orthodoxy will mean more assessments, measuring an ever narrower range of topics and skills to “demonstrate” progress but not in a meaningful way merely an easy to account for way. Indeed the Department for Educations recent return to its desire to see baseline assessments clearly steers to micro managed orthodoxy and away from empowering the teaching profession to apply and develop its own professional agency.
With all of this taken into consideration, a further concern in curating these resources for teachers became how to ensure teachers could make full use of what agency they do have in working with them, so as to best suit the lived experiences of their students. A simplistic but representative example of what I mean is to imagine the different responses you might get by asking a class of students from semi-rural Norfolk where I teach to select an issue to campaign about in the modern world, as compared to those from a class of students from central London. Studying and engaging with the stories of the London Recruits should provide a chance for students in any setting to create their own stories by combining what they learn of the London Recruits with their own lived experiences. In doing so it is hoped they can expand their horizons and have the chance for self-reflection. There is no way to offer means of summatively assessing such things in a standardised fashion, as had been my only experience of creating work for my students in our exam-dominated system thus far. The more I planned activities for the resource-pack, the more a radical notion came to me. Namely, that the teacher working through these resources with their students would be the only person in a position to effectively judge whether students had successfully engaged with, and been engaged by, these materials.
A story worth telling.
In a world recovering from a viral pandemic, with education and other vital services at breaking point due to years of deliberate underinvestment, and a prevailing political discourse of divide and rule pitting those with little against those with even less, inspiring stories like those of the London Recruits are needed more than ever. Not just for what they tell about solidarity, internationalism and that basic human decency which exposes the physical and cultural distance between peoples as the irrelevancies they are, but also for the way they teach this by engaging critical thinking, creativity and compassion.
A classroom teacher’s power to decide what is addressed in the classroom is both the greatest responsibility and privilege of the profession. It is something that the drive to extend academisation, and the workings of Ofsted and of governments, have been keen to reduce. The story of the London Recruits has emerged at the perfect time: there is again debate about what is being taught and why. Teachers have the opportunity, through the resource pack, to take and teach this material because it is a story worth telling.
To obtain copies of the London Recruits Resource Pack visit the NEU website www.neu.org.uk
Steve Marsling is a 70 year old ex-teacher now living on the Suffolk Coast. Steve taught in secondary schools in London, Bristol and Oldham. He also worked in Local Government for the GLC and Lambeth, before becoming an Art Dealer.